PRECISE 111 TUBE
TESTER
Precise 111 advertising
explains why I like this tester a lot!
Here we have a common
advertisement for the Precise Model 111 tube tester. It is a
well written sales pitch, and explains exactly why this tube tester
really does do a better job than much of its competition. The
above advertisement is from the January, 1956 issue of
Radio-Electronics. What is so special about this tube tester?
A few things are worth mentioning.
- A tube can be tester for either mutual conductance or
emission. Yep; a 6L6 can be tested for AC amplification, or
connected as a virtual diode and tested for plate conductance. Why
you would need to do this is a mystery, but I like the option of
testing the amplification capabilities and/or the condition of the
cathode coating.
- Rather than a single plate voltage (as seen on most other tube
testers), the Precise 111 has six different
plate voltages, and you select the one most appropriate (or the
one most likely to be found in the circuit) for the specific tube
under test. This includes selecting voltages to mimic the
'proportional AC voltages' found in Jackson tube testers.
These voltages are still a little less than what is in a
Marshall Major, but a high transconductance tube is
not tested at the same voltages as a low transconductance
tube. This makes for far more accurate readings.
- Also along the path of 'different voltages for different
tubes' is the fact that you select the appropriate Grid signal as
well. Most Hickok tube testers just use one 5VAC test
signal; far too much for high transconductance tubes like the
12AX7. Some testers, like the B&K 747, will always test
a 12AX7 on the lower end of the 'scale'. This is because the
excessive Grid signal forces the Grid to start drawing current,
and this loads down the test signal! The reading is therefore
lower than what would be expected. This is compensated for in the
tube chart. Look for yourself on most any B&K tube
tester (700, 707, 747); the listing for the 12AX7 will have the
note: "Tube 'Good' if it reads '22' or more."
- Grid bias and filament current(!) are also measured on the
meter. This helps you determine if the tube is working under
conditions that it would experience in a real circuit. The
filament current test is useful if you were a 1950's TV repair
technician, and needed to test the behavior of series-string 600mA
tubes.
- Because you can meter everything happening with any tube under
test, you can do a better job of 'matching' output tubes or
dual-triode 'halves'.
This all adds up to one very good tube tester. However, in the
practical world, the Precise 111 has a few things going
against it as well. What could be the downside to such a complete
tube tester?
- As I'll explain below, you absolutely must have the
manual to make the Precise 111 work for you.
- With all the things the Precise 111 will measure, we
need to calibrate everything. There are multiple
'gm' scales, and each needs to be calibrated! We also have to
calibrate the bias voltages, the filament current(!), emission
current, etc., again on each 'gm' scale. This is a
pain-in-the-ass, as tweaking up each of the 1,209 potentiometers
seems to 'upset' the others. Ouch. If you have a lot of patience,
the Precise 111 can be calibrated in less than an
afternoon, and seems to work well. If you do not need accuracy
down to +.000001%, you can calibrate the Precise 111
in about an hour. Below is a photograph of the interior of the
Precise 111, along with six of the aforementioned
calibration potentiometers. You may also note the two rectifier
tubes used in the circuit.
Interior of Precise 111
demonstrates how complex the tester really is.
- The weirdest part about calibrating the Precise 111 is
that we need 'reference tubes' to do the calibrating with! If you
do not have the luxury of owning a 'reference tube', you can
follow these instructions according to the large owner's manual;
"It is suggested that you take the average of several new tubes
- preferably of different manufacturers." Thanks.
All in all, I really like the Precise 111, and use it as
one of my 'go-to' tube testers. To really check a tube over, I will
put it through its paces on my Precise 111, my B&K
747, and my Hickok 752A. I know that's overkill,
but I do a better job at finding borderline tubes with gas,
microphonics, or leakage. Plus I can really match 12AX7
'halves'; always handy for critical phase inverter applications. It
ain't how Leo would have done it; but with today's tubes it
is a necessary evil. As a few final notes; the Precise
111 is also available as the Realistic TK133.
Precise also made a 'little sister' to the Model 111,
which was dubbed the Model 116. An example can be seen below.
Precise 116 was a much
simpler version of the Model 111.
As you may note, the panel is much simpler, with fewer controls.
There are numerous octal sockets, as an example, so the 'Selector'
switch must be set to the appropriate circuit. Also, there is no roll
chart this time around; instead a printed set-up chart is affixed to
the top lid. You cannot meter the bias voltage, nor the filament
current, and there is one 'gm' scale for all tube readings. But you
are measuring the transconductance, and that's the main objective. I
have no advertising for the Precise Model 116, so I cannot
tell you a list price, nor when it debuted on the market. But it is
safe to say it was a simpler, less costly version of the Model
111.
BACK TO THE IDIOT'S
GUIDE TO TUBE TESTERS